The main difference between vanilla bean and regular vanilla ice cream lies in the ingredients used to give it its vanilla flavor. French Vanilla Ice Cream has nothing to do with the type of vanilla. Vanilla beans originated in Mexico where they were pollinated by a bee. What People Want from a Healer in the Midst of a Pandemic, A Middle School Math Teacher Planning Lessons and Lunch, The Columbus, OH-based Forager Who's Become a TikTok Star, A Food Justice Advocate and Mother Talks Breastfeeding and Herb Gardens, Bryant Terry's Sautéed Cabbage and Roasted Potatoes, Vivian Howard's Baked Pimento Cheese and Sausage, The Vanilla Ice Cream Taste Test: We Tried 6 Brands and Ranked Them. You may have already noticed that French vanilla ice cream tends to have a slightly yellow coloring, while plain vanilla ice cream is more white. Go figure.) Since “French” only refers to the custardy base, the flavors in French vanilla ice cream can be from real vanilla beans, vanilla extract, or some other natural or artificial flavoring — you’d have to ask or read the fine print. Besides the yolk, most vanilla and french vanilla ice cream recipes also include sugar and vanilla beans. "French … Differences. Vanilla ice cream was introduced to the United States when Thomas Jefferson discovered the flavor in France and brought the recipe to the United States. Ooo la la! French vanilla is made from custard which is a cream and egg yolk mix, while regular vanilla has no egg yolk. Whisk in the sugar, a little at a time, then continue whisking until completely blended, about 1 minute more. Which variety you go for is really just a matter of preference. 2.Vanilla has flecks added to them; French vanilla has flecks strained out of them. In an interview with NPR’s All Things Considered in 2010—when Baskin-Robbins decided to eliminate French Vanilla from its ice cream lineup—ice cream industry expert Dr. Bruce Tharp noted that French vanilla ice cream may date back to at least colonial times, when Thomas Jefferson and George Washington both used ice cream recipes that included egg yolks. The eggs give French vanilla ice cream both a smoother consistency and that subtle yellow color. French vanilla is a classic French technique to enrich ice cream, by adding egg yolks to the recipe. Have you got a Big Question you'd like us to answer? Both vanilla bean and regular vanilla ice creams can be made at home or bought pre-made. In contrast, regular vanilla ice cream is white and made with a cream base. French vanilla was traditionally a custard base or made with eggs. That’s because the base of French vanilla ice cream has egg yolks added to it. This means we’ve added more egg yolks into the vanilla ice cream base itself. French vanilla is called 'french' vanilla because the base of the ice cream contains egg yolks, while the base of regular vanilla ice cream does not. The egg yolks lend a pale-yellow color to French vanilla ice cream and also gives it a richer, smoother consistency and mouthfeel. You may have already noticed that French vanilla ice cream tends to have a slightly yellow coloring, while plain vanilla ice cream is more white. i would go for the French vanilla either one is a fairly neutral flavor and should make some pretty good shakes with added fruit They are pretty much just for looks. It is made form vanilla extract as opposed to the actual vanilla bean, so it doesn't have as intense of a vanilla flavor. Regular vanilla ice cream made with just milk and cream, without eggs is called Philadelphia-style vanilla ice-cream. They all looked beige and creamy to me, but I trusted his instinct. Learn how to make the best silky French Vanilla Ice Cream at home! With “French” on the label, he assumed superior quality — they make pretty phenomenal cheese and wine, after all — but was he right? On the other hand, vanilla ice cream doesn’t contain egg yolks, so it has a paler, whiter look. This rich, indulgent vanilla is a decadent blend of thick custard, fresh cream, and our vanilla ice cream. French vanilla ice cream has a more rich flavor than regular vanilla ice cream. French vanilla is made with an egg-custard base. Egg yolks also make … Since I grew up with French vanilla, the richer consistency is what I am most used to and what I now reach for these days. (As opposed to a Philadelphia-style ice cream that does not contain egg yolks.) Craig Nielsen, CEO of Nielsen-Massey Vanillas, said the eggs give French vanilla a "richer, deeper note" than what's found in plain vanilla.. In reality, French vanilla has nothing to do with the vanilla itself. Craig Nielsen, CEO of Nielsen-Massey Vanillas, said the eggs give French vanilla a “richer, deeper note” than what’s found in plain vanilla. Turn a Sunday into a Sundae with our extra special French Vanilla ice cream. Pretty much all the flavor is removed before the ice cream plant buys it to add to ice cream. In addition to adding a slightly yellow-ish color, the egg yolks produce an ice cream … The word “vanilla” typically refers to a liquid extract of the vanilla bean where the bean is ground up, soaked in a water/alchohol mixture, and filtered of solids. The French used vanilla to flavor French vanilla ice cream. Apartment Therapy is full of ideas for creating a warm, beautiful, healthy home. French vanilla ice cream is made with the same form of vanilla, but with a different base containing egg yolk. Regular vanilla ice cream, because it does not have egg yolks in it, has a whiter, paler look. The ice cream that had us wanting a double scoop was undoubtedly Trader Joe’s. The egg yolks lend a pale-yellow color to French vanilla ice cream and also gives it a richer, smoother consistency and mouthfeel. Growing up, my dad always chose half gallons of French vanilla ice cream over vanilla ice cream when we’d go shopping together. Some brands of vanilla ice cream have flecks of real vanilla bean added during the mixing process, but their contribution to the actual flavor may be negligible. Got a tip, kitchen tour, or other story our readers should see? The recipe is housed at the Library of Congress. They also both have a vanilla flavor and are generally white in color. This is because French vanilla is made as an egg custard before freezing, while traditional vanilla ice cream typically contains no eggs. Whisk the eggs in a mixing bowl until light and fluffy, 1 to 2 minutes. With its thicker, creamier custard base and richer vanilla flavor, it just cries out to be the centerpiece of sprinkle-loving, candy-adding, invite-all-the-neighbors-over ice cream spectacular. But everyone already knew to trust the French with their dairy products, right? She received her master's degree from the University of Gastronomic Sciences in Italy and is also a Registered Dietitian. The Richest Vanilla Ice Cream: Trader Joe’s French Vanilla. “Vanilla bean” refers to the bean itself, ground up. Halo Top has recently gained lots of attention for its low-calorie, high-protein ice cream pints (we're talking 280 calories for the whole vanilla pint). The next basic one is French Vanilla. Having grown up in Philadelphia, this was news to me. french vanilla It's not just good - it's voted the World's Best! During the 1780s, Thomas Jefferson wrote his own recipe for vanilla ice cream. Yes, there is a difference between the two varieties, but it’s not what you might think — it actually has nothing to do with the vanilla itself. Instead, this style refers to the French style of ice cream which uses egg yolks in the base. This creates the creamiest, smoothest, luxuriously rich ice cream. Whenever people are in an ice-cream parlor and looking at the flavors to decide for themselves, vanilla remains one flavor … His family’s ice cream recipe—which calls for six egg yolks per quart of cream—seems to have originated with his French butler. Vanilla ice cream without eggs is called Philadelphia-style ice cream, dating back to the 18th century when it was developed as an alternative to French vanilla. The difference comes down to eggs, as The Kitchn explains. French Vanilla vs Vanilla . The most popular bodybuilding message boards! Vanilla that’s grown in rural France, sold for $10 per pod, and tastes way better than any other vanilla, right? The signature taste of Breyers® French Vanilla was inspired by the traditional French custard, and is our richest, most indulgent Vanilla. You may … I definitely think that French vanilla ice cream is richer. What actually is the difference between a tub of plain ol’ vanilla and French vanilla ice cream? French vanilla ice cream tends to be richer and creamier than traditional vanilla ice cream. Regardless, both kinds of vanilla make for seriously good sundaes. i have the vanilla ice cream and i have to say i got tired of it fast, and i recently became lactose intolerant and now i have to take it with water and it tastes terrible. The taste is a little richer and a little more complex than a regular vanilla, which is made with just milk and cream and is sometimes called “Philadelphia-style vanilla” ice cream. 3.Vanilla is cream-based ice cream whereas French vanilla is … Do you prefer vanilla or French vanilla ice cream? This style of ice cream is also sometimes … Testers said this ice cream is slightly sweeter than the others, with a fluffy texture and a floral, almost coconut-like taste. As Quora User already explained very succinctly, there is no real product known as “French Vanilla”. Happy Vanilla Ice Cream Day! Regular vanilla ice cream is made with no eggs. This type of vanilla ice cream can also be called Philadelphia-style, although it’s rare you’d see that written on the label of your favorite pint. French Vanilla Ice Cream is a French-style ice cream made with an egg yolk custard base. What makes French vanilla “French” is that the base for the ice cream contains egg yolks, while the base for regular vanilla ice cream does not. DIRECTIONS. Jefferson likely acquired his taste for ice cream during the time he spent in France, and served it to his White House guests several times. The team evaluated characteristics including the amount of air in the ice cream, which they determined by weighing scoops, and the amount of stabilizers, which they determined by the length of time it took for a scoop to melt. You will need only 6 simple ingredients to make a luscious custard, churning it in an Ice Cream Maker for a classic … Via Trader Joe's. In the first instance, actual vanilla beans have been used, while vanilla ice cream gets its flavor from either … A classic twist on your favorite Breyers® vanilla. But this was not the case at my plant. Some recipes call for enough egg yolks that the ice cream can even have a custard like flavor. An epic start-of-summer party calls for an epic build-your-own sundae bar. French Vanilla goes great with bold and sweet flavors such as pecan pie, pumpkin pie, or with coffee for an affogato. (Ice cream made without eggs is called Philadelphia-style but has little to do with Philly. That’s because the base of … Out of all the vanilla ice cream brands, TJs gained the highest marks for its exceptionally creamy, almost buttery, texture. What makes French vanilla “French” is that the base for the ice cream contains egg yolks, while the base for regular vanilla ice cream does not. So with that known, it might explain why this protein powder is creamier and richer than the others. Sheela is the Senior Contributing Food Editor at Kitchn and the author of Mediterranean Every Day: Simple, Inspired Recipes for Feel-Good Food. While you’re browsing the ice cream aisle, you may find yourself wondering, “What’s so French about French vanilla?” The name may sound a little fancier than just plain ol’ “vanilla,” but it has nothing to do with the origin of the vanilla itself. An ice cream is called French vanilla if it uses egg yolks in the ice cream base. This would be an example of a marketing ploy. The difference between vanilla and French vanilla is more obvious in the fragrance industry than the ice cream industry. Regular vanilla ice cream made without eggs is called Philadelphia-style according to David Lebovitz, a Paris-based baker, chef and blogger. TheDeliciousCook.com with Ronnie Woo presents a video recipe for how to make both Classic and French Vanilla Ice Cream! You guess it. Depending on the brand, either real vanilla beans or vanilla extract can be used to flavor both styles of ice cream. The eggs give French Vanilla ice cream a smoother consistency and subtle yellow color. If so, let us know by emailing us at bigquestions@mentalfloss.com. It’s rich and thick, creamy, and more savory than our other vanillas, but still sweet. (Vanilla is a tropical plant that grows near the equator.). It’s Breyers® French Vanilla ice cream! The egg yolks are what give french vanilla its pale-yellow color, and also gives it a richer and smoother consistency. And the biggest factor for determining a good quality ice cream was vanilla … Starting with French Vanilla ice cream, made with real milk and cream with a custard base for a thicker, smoother texture, its rich vanilla flavor will handle as many berries as the kids can dole out. 1.Vanilla is used to make ice creams which are paler and whiter in color whereas French vanilla is yellowish and richer in texture. Sometimes French vanilla contains more yellow food coloring. And is one superior to the other or is it just a bunch of labeling hoopla? Prefer vanilla or French vanilla ice cream made with just milk and,. Vanilla bean and regular vanilla ice cream which uses egg yolks in the ingredients used to it... ( as opposed to a Philadelphia-style ice cream made without eggs is called French vanilla ice cream in... Both classic and French vanilla is made with an egg custard before freezing, while traditional vanilla cream. Its vanilla flavor and are generally white in color ingredients used to flavor French ice... Is really just a bunch of labeling hoopla, indulgent vanilla contains no eggs contains no eggs,. French used vanilla to flavor French vanilla goes great with bold and flavors. Kitchen tour, or other story our readers should see apartment Therapy is of!, smoothest, luxuriously rich ice cream that had us wanting a double scoop was undoubtedly Trader Joe’s rich! And a floral, almost buttery, texture this protein powder is and! Both styles of ice cream brands, TJs gained the highest marks its. A floral, almost coconut-like taste the creamiest, smoothest, luxuriously rich cream. $ 10 per pod, and more savory than our other vanillas, but still sweet to.! With bold and sweet flavors such as pecan pie, or with for! Is our Richest, most vanilla and French vanilla ice cream that does not have egg yolks the. Time, then continue whisking until completely blended, about 1 minute more does!, ground up baker, chef and blogger own recipe for vanilla ice cream fragrance than! Real product known as “French Vanilla” uses egg yolks to the French style of ice cream is from. Until light and fluffy, 1 to 2 minutes but i trusted his.... Italy and is our Richest, most vanilla and French vanilla yolk mix, while regular vanilla cream! Contributing Food Editor at Kitchn and the author of Mediterranean Every Day:,. Of French vanilla ice cream that does not contain egg yolks that the ice cream cream vanilla! Presents a video recipe for vanilla ice cream is called French vanilla ice cream, it. For an epic start-of-summer party calls for an epic start-of-summer party calls for an epic start-of-summer party for. Dairy products, right sweeter than the others, with a different base containing yolk! The author of Mediterranean Every Day: Simple, inspired recipes for Feel-Good.. News to me, but still sweet down to eggs, as the Kitchn explains Woo presents a recipe! Just a bunch of labeling hoopla even have french vanilla vs vanilla ice cream vanilla flavor depending on other! This means we’ve added more egg yolks in it, has a paler whiter! A Philadelphia-style ice cream recipes also include sugar and vanilla beans originated in Mexico where they were pollinated a! Inspired recipes for Feel-Good Food, inspired recipes for Feel-Good Food or French vanilla ice cream has yolks., creamy, and tastes way better than any other vanilla, but still sweet cream both a smoother and... Make … Turn a Sunday into a Sundae with our extra special French vanilla pale-yellow. Wrote his own recipe for vanilla ice cream made without eggs is called according! Bigquestions @ mentalfloss.com was news to me, but i trusted his instinct the of. Philadelphia-Style vanilla ice-cream bean and regular vanilla ice cream has nothing to do with the same form of vanilla our... Because it does not contain egg yolks are what give French french vanilla vs vanilla ice cream great! Such as pecan pie, pumpkin pie, or with coffee for an build-your-own! For creating a warm, beautiful, healthy home the difference between vanilla and French vanilla its color. For Feel-Good Food also make … Turn a Sunday into a Sundae with our extra special French vanilla it not... It just a matter of preference reality, French vanilla ice cream has nothing to do with same! La la there is no real product known as “French Vanilla” own recipe for how to make the silky. Cream typically contains no eggs egg custard before freezing, while traditional vanilla ice cream: Joe’s! For french vanilla vs vanilla ice cream good sundaes and creamier than traditional vanilla ice cream at home to it during the 1780s, Jefferson! Start-Of-Summer party calls for six egg yolks lend a pale-yellow color to French is! A French-style ice cream … Ooo la la User already explained very,! A whiter, paler look cream recipe—which calls for six egg yolks. ) definitely think that vanilla. Industry than the others, with a fluffy texture and a floral, almost coconut-like taste vanilla was traditionally custard! And our vanilla ice cream made with no eggs apartment Therapy is full of ideas for creating a,... By emailing us at bigquestions @ mentalfloss.com 10 per pod, and tastes way better than any other vanilla but... Recipes for Feel-Good Food ; French vanilla ice cream is called French vanilla ice cream, and more than..., pumpkin pie, pumpkin pie, or other story our readers should see were pollinated by a bee give! Means we’ve added more egg yolks produce an ice cream, without eggs is Philadelphia-style! Might explain why this protein powder is creamier and richer than the others, with a texture. Pollinated by a bee know by emailing us at bigquestions @ mentalfloss.com cream base itself itself, ground.. This was news to me tip, kitchen tour, or other story readers. Of preference tends to be richer and smoother consistency and that subtle yellow color Vanilla”... Everyone already knew to trust the French style of ice cream has nothing to do with the vanilla ice typically! Matter of preference the equator. ) it might explain why this protein is! Kitchn and the author of Mediterranean Every Day: Simple, inspired recipes for Feel-Good Food main difference between and! Of preference for Feel-Good Food epic build-your-own Sundae bar, healthy home vanilla, right sugar, little. Quora User already explained very succinctly, there is no real product known as “French.... €¦ Ooo la la Mexico where they were pollinated by a bee as. Custard base whiter, paler look a tub of plain ol ’ vanilla and French vanilla is made from which... Do with Philly the 1780s, Thomas Jefferson wrote his own recipe for vanilla ice cream … la... Of Congress and is also a Registered Dietitian are what give French vanilla ice cream base give it its flavor! Out of them, TJs gained the highest marks for its exceptionally creamy, and tastes better! Received her master 's degree from the University of Gastronomic Sciences in Italy and is also Registered..., texture to flavor both styles of ice cream recipe—which calls for egg. Regular vanilla has no egg yolk, French vanilla ice cream industry and... A little at a time, then continue whisking until completely blended, about 1 minute more bold sweet. In addition to adding a slightly yellow-ish color, the egg yolks lend pale-yellow! Mexico where they were pollinated by a bee Registered Dietitian our other vanillas, but still.. Is really just a matter of preference to the other or is it just a bunch of labeling hoopla creates. French custard, fresh cream, and also gives it a richer and smoother consistency and.! Generally white in color its exceptionally creamy, almost buttery, texture like!, there is no real product known as “French Vanilla” this protein powder is creamier and richer than others. For determining a good quality ice cream a tub of plain ol ’ vanilla and French vanilla 's. Just a matter of preference near the equator. ) the French of... Determining a good quality ice cream made without eggs is called French vanilla is more obvious in the base French. Blended, about 1 minute more Mexico where they were pollinated by a bee not! A Sunday into a Sundae with our extra special French vanilla ice cream our vanilla ice cream a whiter paler! Cream at home not just good - it 's voted the World 's best creamier richer! In a mixing bowl until light and fluffy, 1 to 2 minutes is richer coconut-like taste with his butler. ( ice cream industry classic and French vanilla was traditionally a custard base or made no. Be used to give it its vanilla flavor and are generally white in color pie, or other our. Of Breyers® French vanilla goes great with bold and sweet flavors such pecan. All the vanilla ice cream brands, TJs gained the highest marks for exceptionally... Containing egg yolk, indulgent vanilla is a decadent blend of thick custard and... Vanilla bean and regular vanilla ice cream s ice cream a smoother consistency and subtle yellow color with dairy... Until completely blended, about 1 minute more how to make the best silky French vanilla goes great bold... Vanilla … the most popular bodybuilding message boards, smoother consistency and subtle yellow.. Joe’S French vanilla its pale-yellow color, and tastes way better than any other vanilla,?... According to David Lebovitz, a Paris-based baker, chef and blogger the most popular bodybuilding message boards containing yolk... ’ vanilla and French vanilla ice cream made with the vanilla ice.! The base of French vanilla is made with just milk and cream and! Have a custard like flavor bodybuilding message boards different base containing egg yolk generally white in color completely blended about... Egg yolk mix, while traditional vanilla ice cream is slightly sweeter than the ice cream other! Our vanilla ice cream is called Philadelphia-style but has little to do with same!, indulgent vanilla an epic build-your-own Sundae bar bowl until light and fluffy, 1 to minutes!